Eternals

Score:  A-

Directed by Chloe Zhao

Starring Richard Madden, Gemma Chan, Angelina Jolie, Salma Hayek, Kumail Nanjiani

Running time: 157 minutes

Rated PG-13

Long Story Short:  Eternals introduces a host of new heroes in this post-Avengers Marvel world, and these guys are quite literally heavenly.  With a sprawling, fantastical premise and so many characters, a fine balance was necessary; many critics assert that it failed to find it.  But I was impressed by this true team - no individual stands above the rest - and Oscar-winning director Zhao's focus on them, through whom the action and everything else becomes more engrossing and specific.

Thousands of years ago, just as human civilizations began to emerge, a group of ten beings called Eternals were sent to Earth to protect our ancestors from alien predators.  The Eternals hunted these aliens for many years, and remained on Earth through the present day, disguised as regular people.  When two of the Eternals, Sersi (Chan) and Sprite (McHugh), are attacked, they suspect that the pattern they've followed for thousands of year has been disrupted.  As they reunite with the other Eternals, Sersi learns more that challenges what she thinks she knows.  Having settled in among the humans, Sersi is shaken awake to the stakes involved not just for the planet but for worlds beyond.

Eternals, despite being part of the Marvel movie universe I love, shares many elements of movies that don't tend to work well; but somehow, it does work here.  It's similar to the Avengers - and especially Infinity War and Endgame - in that properly balancing a large number of characters, the background (which in this case is entirely new), and the current plot is enormously challenging.  The big risk is that so many elements will end up as window dressing within a busy but incoherent two-and-a-half hours.  Fortunately, Marvel has continued to land the most appropriate directors, from the hidden gems (Joe and Anthony Russo) to bigger names - in this case, recent Best Director Oscar winner, Chloe Zhao.  I haven't seen her other work yet, sadly, though I do know that it is almost in the opposite of a Marvel blockbuster.  Zhao and the screenwriters wisely stick to the Marvel tradition of focusing on the hero characters while balancing the action and plot pretty effectively; at least, in my opinion.

Marvel movies have become associated with their interconnectedness; not just returning characters, but narratives that run through a dozen and more films.  Well, Eternals is about the least connected Marvel movie I've seen in a long time.  I actually missed the main connection while watching it, but I can safely say it doesn't affect your enjoyment or understanding of the movie.  The reason it's relatively standalone is that the premise starts literally at the beginning - how Earth was formed and humans developed (Marvel's fictional version, of course).  Eternals doesn't bombard you with all the details at the beginning, though; you get just enough to start, and then a combination of flashbacks and a bit of present-day dialogue fills in the rest of the picture.  The movie's first action scene follows the initial exposition; it and a few other skirmishes throughout are admittedly ho-hum, by Marvel standards.  But there is more tension in the action scenes than usual, as several heroes die in the film, a rarity for Marvel; despite their raw power, there is a clear sense of their vulnerability.  An action scene in the Amazon is particularly good, with multiple phases, unpredictability, and emotion.

The crowd of heroes that make up the Eternals - ten in all - are a charismatic bunch, helping to increase concern for their fates in those action scenes.  While there are no true standouts, most give solid to very good performances, and Zhao uses their contrasting personalities to maintain energy and variety through the long running time while minimizing the downside of not being able to focus on any one for too long.  Sersi (Chan) and Ikaris (Madden) bring a more traditional romance to the Marvel universe, though one clearly shaped by their powers and mission.  Kingo (Nanjiani) and Phastos (Henry) bring the comedic element though in distinct forms, while Sprite (McHugh) and Druig (Keoghan) bring sharp contrarian personalities.  And there's even more, if somewhat overshadowed: Thena (Jolie) brings both power and vulnerability, and Makkari (Ridloff) confidently represents the differently-abled.  The plot is interesting and, in the main, straightforward enough to follow without straining (I got lost on a few supporting elements, but it didn't matter).  Yet it is the journey of following these characters, as they go from ancient alien saviors to present-day individuals immersed in humanity, that drives the movie.  We don't get any images of civilians fleeing the crumbling of a city (though there is an epic CGI creation to behold); Zhao instead trusts the audience to see the global - and galactic - stakes through her ten heroes.  The final battle, reminiscent of a great one in Infinity War, pits the heroes against their own motivations more than any external enemy.  You can quibble with the execution of this scene or that one, the pacing, and so on, but Zhao truly directed Eternals in just the way it had to be.

***

Eternals brings yet another dimension to the Marvel movie universe: a historic, almost divine one.  I am glad that they let this one stand pretty much on its own, post-credits sequences aside.  And despite the length, I am also even more interested than I usually am to see this one again in the theater.  Critics have savaged this movie, which I think is mostly because they are tired of Marvel movies and are eager to pounce at the slightest opportunity to be negative.  It certainly is not a perfect film, but if they actually gave it a fair chance with an open mind, I feel more would see it the way I do.  I encourage you to try it for yourself, whether or not you are a Marvel fan!

* By http://www.impawards.com/2021/eternals_ver3.html, Fair use, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=67750433