Sinners

 

Score:  A-/B+

Directed by Ryan Coogler

Starring Michael B. Jordan, Miles Caton, Wunmi Mosaku, Hailee Steinfeld, Delroy Lindo, et al

Running time: 138 minutes

Rated R

Long Story Short: Sinners is a period drama/horror picture, the brain child of writer and director Ryan Coogler (Creed, Black Panther).  His talent is on full display in illustrating an enterprising duo (both played by Michael B. Jordan) pushing through the challenges of Depression-Era Mississippi to open a bar.  Things get much more intriguing as they get closer to their dream, through both phenomenal music and nighttime terrors.  The dots don't all connect as perfectly as you might hope, but it's still an original, entertaining and well-made movie.  Highly recommended.

Twin brothers Smoke and Stack (Jordan) have returned to the Mississippi Delta in 1932, having tired of their lives in Chicago and craving a triumphant return home.  They decide to open a new bar with the last of their money, and their plan to strike gold is to employ the best musicians in the area: blues pianist Delta Slim (Lindo) and singer (Pearline), and a secret introduction, their young cousin and guitar prodigy Sammie (Caton).  The twins assemble a strong staff around them and celebrate with a packed-house opening night.  However, the joyful music attracts more menacing neighbors, and the innocent party soon takes on more deadly stakes.

Sinners is an enjoyable genre mashup, both period drama and horror, that features impressive music and visuals.  I had even less idea of what to expect from this than most movies; all I knew was that it was partly a horror movie, which I usually avoid, but I was drawn in by director Coogler and its high critics scores.  The movie ends up focusing primarily on the drama and relationships of developing the new bar, with the horror coming in relatively late.  I most enjoyed the dramatic parts, of course, although it was a bit frustrating not being able to tell where it was all going (a sense that was not helped by characters' hard-to-understand Southern accents).  The horror element is interesting at first, too, especially when it's tied directly to the drama, but it builds to a disappointingly standard action climax.  Lifting up all parts of the movie - featuring an especially excellent dream/hallucination-like scene near the middle - are the music and the visuals.  Great blues music is played by Delta Slim, Pearline, and Sammie.  We get samples of it as they are forming the bar, then fully unleashed on opening night.  Even the bad guys also have some pleasant music, though they use a very different musical style.  The cinematography and  visuals are also great, though more subtle for the most part (except, again, for the standout middle scene and as the horror ramps up).

The acting in Sinners is very strong overall, with a rich cast of a variety of characters.  Jordan has a lot of charisma and screen presence as always, although his persona - which is identical (to me) between the twins - is basically his standard tough/cool guy.  Caton's Sammie is the more interesting character to me, with good acting, great musical performance, and a more complex, conflicted personality - music isn't the only thing in his background.  All of the supporting characters are good, and I especially liked Lindo's Delta Slim and a Chinese couple with a small but distinctive role.  It was interesting to watch the details and difficulties of setting up the bar, with not only racism but the Depression to deal with; the twins are strong and savvy, but it's still not easy to recruit their talent, secure supplies, and land a location.  While watching I had a growing sense that Sinners was akin to Get Out, in producing a clever metaphor for the racial challenges of the time and place.  Instead, Sinners is more straightforward with its presentation of racial struggle.  While there is an interesting mystical element, it is tied more to the music; I feel it could have also tied in more strongly (and artistically) with race, too, if the action/gore was held in check and instead further develop character relations.  Although maybe I just missed it - I intentionally did not read anyone else's review yet!  But even if I did, I still found it to be a very good, well-made and entertaining movie.

***

Sinners is yet another original (aka, not a sequel or part of an existing franchise) that I've seen this year, which is an encouraging trend.  Especially when it's made by a proven filmmaker like Ryan Coogler, I jump at the chance to see these in the theater.  I admit that I didn't like it quite as much as what the stupendous reviews on Rotten Tomatoes suggest (98% from critics and 97% from audiences!).  That could be due partly to my aversion to horror, partly to my comparing it to Get Out.  But really, it's nitpicking.  I'm glad to see that it is doing well at the box office, hopefully encouraging studios to make more movies like it (not the specific topic/genre, but 1) creative original ideas, and 2) led by talented filmmakers).  With April almost over, that means it's almost time for summer movie season.  That surely means more sequels and franchise fare, but I'm mostly OK with that: particularly with a Marvel-version of Suicide Squad, a new Pixar, the final Mission Impossible, and a rebooted Jurassic Park.  Until next time!

* By IMP Awards, Fair use, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=77948449